This entry is for the 6th Golden Boy Blogathon hosted by Ginnie from The Wonderful World of Cinema and yours truly!
In 1950, Mr. William Holden just became a superstar with his breakout role as Joe Gillis in Billy Wilder’s Sunset Blvd. One would think a slew of immediate hits would follow, but they actually slowly trickled in, and Bill didn’t receive his next major movie until reuniting with Wilder for his Oscar winning role in 1953’s Stalag 17. During that three year period, Bill did have steady work and even one hit with 1950’s Born Yesterday (which got Oscar noms including best picture and a win for his co star Judy Holliday).
I find this 1950-1953 time span of Bill’s career to be insanely intriguing, as here you have a breakout superstar after he had been working in Hollywood for over a decade, yet after Sunset Blvd, he basically goes straight back to working in random roles in films the studio tells him to do. While results are mixed, I think all of the movies had an over looked quality to them, as critics like to jump straight to 1953 and beyond. Submarine Command (1951) I count as one of these overlooked movies, and I think part of that is lack of DVD and little airplay on TV. I myself personally did not even find this movie until I stumbled upon it on YouTube one night and decided to jump at the chance to watch it. (It is finally being rescued by Kino Lorber and will have a blu ray release!)
Co-starring his Sunset Blvd leading lady Nancy Olson in their fourth and final pairing, Submarine Command is one of the first movies ever to address the then unknown feelings of PTSD. Lieutenant Commander Ken White (Bill) is out at sea in the Pacific theater of war, in charge of the USS Tiger Shark. Taking cover during a Japanese air raid, White orders the submarine to submerge, despite a warning from CPO Boyer (William Bendix), that the captain, Commander Josh Rice (Jack Gregson) is still on top.
White refuses to listen to the advice of Boyer and submerges anyway; unfortunately Rice and a fellow crewman are both lost. Even more alarming is when the sub resurfaces, they are made aware WW2 is now over. Filled with guilt, and even though NO one but Boyer holds a grudge against him (Rice’s family does not blame him), White goes back to civilian life and chooses to remain in the Navy in a desk position.
Things go OK for White and he even marries his sweetheart Carol (Nancy Olson), until one day he gets news Tiger Shark is being recommissioned with Boyer as a fellow crew member. Boyer automatically tries to transfer, but is unsuccessful. It gets even worse when a fire breaks out on the Tiger Shark, and White makes Boyer follow the proper protocol when saving a trapped man, rather than jumping into immediate action.
Believing he can take no more, White actually makes plans to leave the Navy and all of his past demons behind until he gets news the Korean War has started. He takes control of Tiger Shark again, believing his new mission of saving two PoWs with vital war info is his last chance at redemption.
In terms of plot (including battle/action sequences), Submarine Command directed by John Farrow is probably not the most original, and is certainly predictable. It’s even been cited by some as one of the worst WW2 movies in terms of action and accuracy, but what I focus on is the actual emotion these actors are portraying. PTSD was a known feeling amongst fellow vets, just not formally or medically diagnosable. My own grandfather who was Army Infantry in WW2 certainly had un-diagnosed PTSD, and I can’t help but wonder how disillusioned he must have felt. Almost never talking about war was his style, but one thing he did remind me of, is he wanted further and future WW2 education to be about the everyday people who were there, and this is just what this movie is focused on: war vets.
I know some may say the manner in which PTSD was overdone, or unrealistic, and while that MAY BE true given modern day assessments, what is also true is this movie got the ball rolling on bringing the issue to light. Bill I think 100% could draw on his own war time experience, and I think he was just marvelous at portraying a disillusioned man you care about. Whether it be a fed up screenwriter frustrated with Hollywood OR a Navy submarine commander wanting to atone for his wrongdoings, Bill so honestly portrayed the emotion in a raw and real way. (I only wish I had my Grandfather’s pov of this movie, but I think he would enjoy it, as he often liked movies with interesting characters and plots.)
I also find the inclusion of family and domestic life an interesting part of the narrative. Although the Whites are newlyweds without children, it’s so evident Ken’s PTSD is damaging their relationship. You see his anger and inability to address his issues, while on Carol’s part, you see her wanting to help her husband, but not really sure how to do so. Husband-Wife and wartime relationships would be a recurring element in one of Bill’s films going forward with a similar situation appearing in The Bridges at Toko-Ri (1954).
Unexpectedly, this movie gave me the personal theory that lead guitarist Ace Frehley of Kiss took inspiration from this movie for the song “Torpedo Girl” from the 1980 Unmasked album. I have strong reason to suspect it was, but even if it isn’t, to possibly believe Bill and my favorite guitarist could possibly be someone artistically connected with this work is a cool possibility. Ace was born in April 1951, which he often likes to make references to, and consider, this movie was made in 1951. This movie contains the line Man (your) battle stations, Torpedo, which Ace uses as the opening lines of the song. According to this official torpedo phrases reference guide, such a line does not exist, as similar phrases do but not exact verbatim. Finally at about the 5 min mark of the film, Bill as his character Ken White says it looks like a nice day for a swim, which Ace says the lyric, “I thought I’d go out and take a swim today“, in the first verse.
Overall, I am so thankful I watched Submarine Command and I want to thank Kino Lorber for rescuing it by putting it on on disc for the first time ever! I have it pre-ordered 🙂 and can’t wait to watch the new restoration! Bill’s lesser but hidden gems of movies are just a fun to watch as his legendary hits- and this movie is a prime and fine example of that! Would you expect anything less from the Golden Holden!!!??!!
Happy 106th birthday Bill!!!!!!